Bluestone paving with natural blue-gray and brown variation

Bluestone, Fieldstone or Pavers? Choosing Patio Stone in Westchester

Posted by on

By Sean Alvarez, President, Perennial Gardens Bedford

For a terrace on a Westchester property, bluestone is the usual first choice: it is regional, it suits the fieldstone walls already on the land, and it can be laid formal or loose. Fieldstone and flagstone suit a garden terrace with an older feel. Granite is the most durable and the most formal. Concrete pavers are uniform and economical, but they rarely look as if they belong to an old Bedford property.

The right stone depends on the house, the walls already standing, how the terrace is used and how much sun it takes.

A random-pattern stone terrace with an outdoor dining table, edged by planting

A random-pattern stone terrace with dining room, on one of our Westchester projects.

The materials at a glance

Material Look Underfoot Best for
Bluestone, natural cleft Blue-gray with variation into brown; a riven, textured face Good grip; slightly uneven Terraces, walks and steps with a regional character
Bluestone, thermal finish More uniform color; a flat, flame-finished face Smooth and even; good for furniture Formal terraces, pool surrounds, treads and coping
Fieldstone and flagstone Irregular, weathered, regional Uneven by nature Garden terraces and paths near old walls
Granite and Belgian block Gray, precise, formal Very hard-wearing; block is bumpy for furniture Edging, borders, steps and formal paving
Concrete pavers Uniform; wide range of colors and shapes Even Budget-led or contemporary designs

Samples of bluestone, Belgian block, fieldstone and cobblestone side by side

Bluestone

Bluestone brings the character of the region's stone walls to flat surfaces. It can be laid as random flagstone, with irregular joints that read informal, or as gauge-cut rectangles in a pattern that reads architectural. A natural cleft face has texture and grip; a thermal finish is flatter and more even, which suits dining furniture and pool decks.

Two cautions. Darker stone holds heat, so a bluestone terrace in full afternoon sun is warm underfoot in July. And bluestone has moderate salt sensitivity, so use an alternative deicer on bluestone steps in winter.

Rectangular cut-stone paving around an outdoor kitchen

Cut stone laid in a pattern reads more architectural than random flagstone.

Fieldstone and flagstone

Fieldstone is the stone of Bedford's old walls. As paving it gives a looser, older look, best for garden terraces and paths that sit near walls already on the property, with planting allowed into the joints. It is less even underfoot than cut stone, so it suits strolling more than dining.

Fieldstone walls and planting along a stone path beside a house

Fieldstone walls and a stone path laid to sit with the land.

Granite and Belgian block

Granite is the hardest-wearing of the natural stones. Belgian block, which is cut granite, is used for edging and borders, the crisp line between a terrace and a lawn or a drive. Bedford-sourced granite has the gray-with-pink-flecks character of the walls already standing across town. We compare Belgian block, bluestone and cobblestone underfoot in our guide to stone driveways.

Concrete pavers

Manufactured pavers are uniform, quick to lay and economical, and individual units can be lifted and replaced. The trade-off is character: they do not match regional stone, and color and surface weather over time. On a property with old fieldstone walls, natural stone almost always looks more at home.

Dry-laid or mortar-set

Dry-laid stone sits on a compacted gravel base with sand or stone-dust joints. It flexes with the freeze-thaw cycle, drains through the joints and is simple to repair. Joints need occasional topping up.

Mortar-set stone sits on a concrete slab with mortared joints. The result is tighter and more formal, but it depends entirely on a base that does not move; when a slab cracks, the stone above it follows.

In both cases the base does more of the work than the stone. Most failed patios in this climate failed underneath: too little compacted base, or water with nowhere to go.

Stone treads, fieldstone walls and planting stepping down to a pool

Stone treads and fieldstone walls stepping down to a pool.

How we approach a terrace

We start with the house and the walls already standing, then the way the terrace will be used: a dining terrace wants an even surface, a garden path wants character. We walk the property, talk through what you want from it, and follow with a detailed proposal covering material specifications and a timeline. See our stone walls, steps and patios page for how we build.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best patio stone for a Westchester property?

For most Bedford-area houses, bluestone. It is regional, it suits the fieldstone walls already on the land, and it can be laid formal or informal. Fieldstone suits a looser, garden-style terrace; concrete pavers suit a budget-led or very contemporary design.

Does bluestone get hot in the sun?

It can. Darker stone absorbs heat, so a bluestone terrace in full afternoon sun is warm underfoot in summer. Shade, a lighter thermal finish or a planting plan that shades the hottest hours all help.

Is bluestone damaged by road salt?

It can be. Bluestone has moderate salt sensitivity, so use an alternative deicer on bluestone steps and terraces.

Dry-laid or mortar-set?

Dry-laid stone sits on a compacted gravel base, flexes with the freeze-thaw cycle and is easy to repair. Mortar-set stone sits on a concrete slab for tight, formal joints, and depends on a base that does not move.

← Older Post

Field Notes

RSS
Front entry dressed with fresh garland, a wreath and red velvet bows
Floral Holiday

How to Keep Fresh Holiday Greens and Wreaths Looking Their Best

By Tim McVey

Cold, shade and distance from heat keep fresh wreaths and garlands green through the season. A florist's notes for Westchester doors, mantels and planters.

Read more
Fresh balsam fir, white pine and cedar branches on a work table
Garden Center Holiday

Choosing a Christmas Tree: Fraser, Balsam or Concolor Fir?

By Augie Alvarez

Fraser holds its needles, Balsam has the scent, Concolor has the color. How to choose a fresh-cut tree in Bedford and keep it green to...

Read more
Perennial Gardens Bedford New York 33

Planning a project on your property?

Sean Alvarez and our landscape team design and build gardens, stonework and pool landscapes across Westchester and Fairfield County. Every project begins with a consultation.

Book a landscape consultation